Democracy Now at Pacifica Radio: Can WBAI
Be Saved? by Nat Hentoff for The
Village Voice | April 17, 2001
Before WBAI became part of Pacifica Radio network, it was located
at the Hotel Pierre and the owner was Louis Schweitzer, a rather
eccentric man of considerable means. Gunther Schuller and I had a
weekly jazz program on WBAI then; and one night, between sets at the
Village Gate, Schweitzer told me that he was going to donate WBAI to
Pacifica Radio. He wanted to hear classical music more often, and he
felt that this city needed a station with network resources, which
would provide news and analysis that the mainstream media didn't
have the knowledge or the courage to air.
Schweitzer was a liberal in the old sense of the word -- he
believed that democracy requires a wide diversity of ideas. For many
years, WBAI and Pacifica adhered to the principles of both
Schweitzer and the network's founder, Lewis Hill, a nonsectarian
pacifist. The best concise description of the programming, both in
New York and on the four other affiliates around the country, was
Frank Ahrens's in The Washington Post: "valuable journalism, mixed
with some wild-eyed zealotry."
Through the years, I've been interviewed on the Pacifica
network's news programs -- now much less independent under the
present national board -- and I have freely criticized "political
correctness" on the left, including at Pacifica and WBAI. I also had
some very lively exchanges with congressional supporters of Bill
Clinton during the impeachment proceedings. But as the national
board began to include corporate-style members who had little in
common with the visions of Lewis Hill and Louis Schweitzer, pressure
started to build to attract more mainstream listeners, who might be
turned off by the occasional "wild-eyed zealotry" and the frequently
penetrating reporting on local, national, and world affairs. Of
particular value is Amy Goodman's network program, Democracy NOW!,
which originates at WBAI and covers the universe -- as George Seldes
and I.F. Stone might have done as broadcasters.
Pressure has also been mounting on Goodman to be more circumspect
-- but she resists. In July 1999, at Pacifica affiliate KPFA in
Berkeley, California -- which Lewis Hill hoped would be a national
model for listener-sponsored, community-based radio -- the clash
between the current board and Hill's dream turned into a nightmare.
Considering KPFA too "radical" -- and therefore a less valuable
property if the national board wanted to sell it -- the board fired
the station manager, locked out protesting staffers, and imposed a
gag rule to prevent listeners from knowing what was going on. One
commentator who broke the rule was dragged out of the KPFA newsroom
in mid-sentence by security personnel. (See the updated Pacifica
Radio: The Rise of an Alternative Network, by Matthew Lasar, Temple
University Press.)
It is that style of management that WBAI's interim general
manager, Utrice Leid, has perpetrated on dissenting staffers. She
has fired and banned an increasing number of them, and as I reported
last week, she cut Congressman Major Owens off the air as he was
recalling the original intent of WBAI and Pacifica. Leid has tried,
with some success, to impose a gag rule on the remaining members of
the staff, but some keep on keeping faith with the listeners. In
March of this year, the Pacifica National Board met in Houston. Also
insistently present were some 200 protesting listeners and staff
members of the five Pacifica stations. According to the ad hoc
National Organizing Committee -- composed of dissenters who want to
save the network from further pollution of its founding principles
-- "in the most dramatic protest, on March 4, nearly the entire
audience turned their backs to the board, chanted, 'Resign now' and
'Democracy now' for 20 minutes, and then walked out, forcing a
recess.
"Later that day, about 100 activists from the five Pacifica
station areas forged the foundation for a nationally coordinated
movement to save Pacifica." A press release from this National
Organizing Committee focused on what it describes as "key board
members who are affiliated with corporate interests, including John
Murdock, an HMO attorney with the union-busting firm of Epstein
Becker & Green." Murdock is head of the board's governance
committee. Also on the national board is Michael Palmer, "a broker
with the commercial real estate firm of CB Richard Ellis; Ken Ford,
a manager with the National Association of Home Builders; and
Bertram Lee, the former Denver Nuggets owner who buys and sells TV
and radio stations."
It may not be likely that these high-level players in the
corporate world would understand why, some years ago, Amy Goodman
literally risked her life to break the story of the slaughtering of
independence fighters in East Timor by Indonesian troops. Nor would
they perhaps understand the importance of Amy Goodman's interview
earlier this year with Bill Clinton, during which he was hit with
the hardest series of questions he has ever faced from the press.
The questions had nothing to do with his sex life.
In Houston, after first closing its Saturday meeting to the
public, the Pacifica board then did let the sunshine in, and, as
reported by the National Organizing Committee: "Protesters packed
the room, festooned with placards denouncing the board, and
delivered demands for board members' resignations." On Friday and
Saturday evenings, speakers at teach-ins were Amy Goodman and Juan
Gonzalez, New York Daily News columnist and cofounder of the
Campaign Against the Corporate Takeover of Pacifica. The National
Organizing Committee reports that a national steering committee is
being established, "composed of elected representatives of the Free
Pacifica listeners groups across the country" -- including New York.
There may be national actions against the board in conjunction
with May Day, and a boycott of contributions to Pacifica stations is
being urged. A committee is being set up to help local activists
rescue Pacifica stations where they are.
If you want to join this retrieval of democracy on the air, the
Pacifica Campaign is at 51 MacDougal Street, Box No. 80, New York,
NY 10012. The Web site is www.pacificacampaign.org, and the phone
number for information about actions being planned is
1-800-797-6229. It also takes messages. In 1999, when the firings
and gag rule took place at KPFA, some 10,000 supporters of free
speech demonstrated in Berkeley, cops were called, and there were
many arrests. In the history of American radio, no station had ever
had so many fervent listeners. Let's see what happens elsewhere.
|